AD

Gas vs. New Energy Vehicles: Comprehensive Comparison of BEV/HEV/PHEV

When purchasing a car, consumers often face the choice between gas-powered vehicles, battery electric vehicles (BEVs), hybrid electric vehicles (HEVs), and plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs). This article provides an in-depth comparison from technical features, usage scenarios, costs, and configurations, while analyzing differences between models in the same class.

AD


1. Core Differences Between Gas and New Energy Vehicles

Comparison AspectGas Car (ICE)BEVHEVPHEV
Power SourceGasoline/DieselBattery + MotorHybrid (No Plug-in)Hybrid (Plug-in)
Range500–1,000 km300–700 km800–1,200 km50–150 km (EV) + Gas
Refueling/Charging5 min (Gas)30 min (Fast Charge, 30–80%)Gas (No Plug)Gas + Charging
Purchase CostLowHigh (Battery Cost)MediumHigher
Operating CostHigh (Fuel + Maintenance)Low (Electricity + Less Maintenance)MediumMedium (EV Mode for Commuting)
Policy SupportNone (License Plate Restrictions)Tax-Free + Subsidies + Green PlatesPartial Green PlatesTax-Free + Green Plates (If EV Range Meets Standards)

2. Detailed Analysis: BEV vs. HEV vs. PHEV

2.1 Battery Electric Vehicle (BEV)

Representative Models: Tesla Model 3, BYD Seal, NIO ET5
Pros:

  • Zero emissions, eco-friendly, no fuel costs.

  • Instant torque (e.g., Model 3 Performance: 0–100 km/h in 3.3s).

  • Low maintenance (no oil/spark plug changes).

  • Policy perks: No purchase tax, no driving restrictions, free green plates (e.g., Shanghai/Beijing).
    Cons:

  • Range anxiety: Cold weather reduces range by 20–30%, long trips depend on charging stations.

  • Charging time: Fast charging still takes 30–40 min (vs. 5 min for gas).

  • Battery degradation: Capacity loss over time (typically 8–15 years before replacement).
    Best For:

  • Urban commuters with home charging.

  • Tech-savvy buyers prioritizing low running costs.

2.2 Hybrid Electric Vehicle (HEV, Non-Plug-In)

Representative Models: Toyota Camry Hybrid, Honda Accord Hybrid
Pros:

  • Ultra-low fuel consumption (4–5L/100km vs. 7–10L for gas cars).

  • No charging needed—just refuel. Ideal for users without charging access.

  • Long battery life (shallow cycles, e.g., Toyota’s THS lasts 10+ years).
    Cons:

  • No green plates (in some Chinese cities, HEVs aren’t classified as NEVs).

  • Weak EV mode (1–2 km range).
    Best For:

  • Frequent long-distance drivers who want fuel efficiency without charging.

  • Conservative buyers trusting proven hybrid tech.

2.3 Plug-In Hybrid (PHEV)

Representative Models: BYD DM-i, Li Auto L-Series, BMW 5 Series PHEV
Pros:

  • EV mode for short trips, gas for long hauls (50–150 km EV range, 1,000+ km total).

  • Green plates + tax exemptions (policy-friendly in China).

  • Strong performance (dual power: e.g., BYD Han DM-p: 0–100 km/h in 3.7s).
    Cons:

  • High fuel use when battery is empty (e.g., Li ONE: 8–10L/100km).

  • Higher upfront cost (¥30K–50K more than gas equivalents).
    Best For:

  • Daily EV commuting + occasional long trips.

  • Buyers needing green plates but wary of pure EV range limits.


3. Same-Class Model Comparison (Midsize Sedan Example)

ModelPowertrain0–100 km/hFuel/Energy UseTrunk Space (L)Infotainment
Toyota CamryGas/HEV8.5s (Gas)6.0L/100km (HEV)524Basic
Tesla Model 3BEV6.1s (RWD)13 kWh/100km425 (Frunk + Trunk)Full Self-Driving
BYD Han DM-iPHEV7.9s1.2L/100km (5.3L匮电)470DiLink OS

Key Takeaways:

  • Space: Gas/HEVs typically have larger trunks (no battery intrusion).

  • Performance: BEVs accelerate fastest, PHEVs next, gas cars slowest.

  • Tech: EV startups (Tesla/NIO) lead; legacy automakers lag.


4. Buying Recommendations

  • BEV: Ideal for urban drivers with home charging.

  • HEV: Best for no-charging access + fuel savings.

  • PHEV: Balances green plates + long-distance flexibility.

  • Gas Cars: Budget-friendly for frequent highway/remote travel.

Future Trends:

  • BEVs will dominate as charging infrastructure improves.

  • PHEVs remain a transitional solution.

  • Gas cars will persist but lose market share.

Final Tip: Test-drive your top choices to compare real-world performance!